Lori (Puff) Sheehy

Associate Real Estate Broker

Photo of Lori (Puff) Sheehy

Lori (Puff) Sheehy
Associate Real Estate Broker

At a glance

My Communities
Mahopac, Kent, Patterson, Putnam Valley, Yorktown, Southeast, Garrison, Cold Spring, Peekskill, Croton-On-Hudson, Somers, Yorktown Heights, Carmel, Brewster, Cortlandt

Lives In
Cortlandt Manor,NY

40 Years

About me

R eal Estate is my passion!  Whether buying or selling, l et me share with you my long-term commitment to my community, its residents and my trade. Serving Westchester, Putnam and Dutchess counties.   More

Professional Associations & Designations

Certified Home Marketing Specialist, Notary Public

Community Involvement

Animal Rescue Groups, CHHOP Supporter, PHS Alumni, The Peekskill Musuem Supporter, The Veterans Advocacy & Benefits Association Supporter.



Numerous Transactions

Lori comes highly recommended. We have experienced her expertise several times and she is a true professional. Always there when needed and very knowledgeable. 


Barbara & Richard Edwards

Highly Recommended

It was difficult finding a house in the current real estate market with so many people looking to move to the Hudson Valley, but Lori was a steady guiding hand. She was patient and willing to go wherever we could find a house that fit my criteria. If you are looking for an agent that is professional and knowledgeable, someone who will help you find the right house, then I would highly recommend Lori Sheehy.



Where do I begin. I guess at the beginning. Hehe, we met Lori on an open house by accident caused by our young curiosity. She spoke about Peekskill with a passion we also shared, and the rest was history. My wife and I were new to the market and knew zero about buying a house. Besides the fact that we needed money everything else was new. Lori gave us a list of financial house keeping that we would need to give some attention to; savings, cleaning up our credit, keeping steady jobs etc. She was patient and happy to help. We have had other people ("agents") that turned us away because we didn't have a pre-approval or any knowledge of the buying process. Lori is beyond an agent. Her job was selling houses but her actions were a testament to her passion. We bought a house in Peekskill in 2017, just closed on our second house in 2020, and we are working again with Lori on our 3rd. When you have a great team with smart passionate people like Lori, the most challenging things can be overcome, the knowledge to get things done gets shared, and everyone feels like they've won. Thank you again Lori.

Aida & Felito


Lori you are AMAZING!!! I couldn't have found a better realtor. You were always on top of things! You did a lot for me, more than I ever expected. Thanks to you I am now a very proud homeowner! Thanks Lori =)

Diana & Christian

You do it expertly!

Hi Lori,

Thank you for being the calm, tolerant person you are.  You helped us through a difficult time in our lives.  I am glad I trusted your determination in getting the house sold.  It's a difficult job!  You do it expertly.

Cathy K.

Exceptional Service

Selling a house could be a stressful event.  So it’s crucial to find a knowledgeable and experienced real estate agent to help the seller navigate through the process.  We were fortunate to find such an agent when we listed our house with Lori Sheehy.  She gave advice on realistic pricing, how to best show the house, kept us updated on the progress of the sale, and after the contract was signed, made sure she followed up with the buyer’s agent.  Because we moved out of the state several weeks before the sale closed, she went above and beyond by making sure that the unoccupied house was kept  in good order and even took care of disposing some household stuff that we had left behind.  We’re very happy to have had Lori’s expert guidance from beginning to end.  She loves her job and it showed.

Beth & Randy E.


"I met Lori 13 months ago when I began my search. My original intention was to buy land and build a house. I was about to make an offer on a parcel when COVID reached the U.S. and I had to make the decision to either wait it out or switch gears and buy an existing house. I chose the latter. Lori was game every step of the way and extraordinarily patient and flexible. We wound up looking for my perfect home in five (5) different counties! Lori truly went above and beyond and happily shuttled me around (I lived in Brooklyn at the time and did not have a car). She is that rare combination of expertise and compassion and is in this field to make people happy. Her local knowledge of the Hudson Valley was incredibly helpful. When all was said and done, we had looked at approximately 30 houses and had four (4) failed offers before finding the perfect home for me. I couldn't have done it without her and am grateful to have made a friend in this crazy process!"

Melissa P.

I did it!

It’s official... I’m a homeowner. Thanks to my family and friends and my realtor Lori Sheehy for putting up with this crazy stressed person these past 5 months.

Mary E.

Step by Step

As a first time buyer, I was a little overwhelmed.  Lori did an exceptional job walking me through the entire process of buying my first home.  Co-ops are tricky, but Lori was there every step of the way.  Could not have done it without her.

Ed S.

Double Play

We so appreciate all your help and what you have done for us.

Thank you for being there for mom through every step.  Definitely couldn't have done it without you!

Ruthe & Patrice

We love Lori!

Lori is the best! She was extremely patient, sweet lady and super punctual. She made our first time home buying process a great experience. We will definitely call Lori first if we ever decide to sell or buy again. She helped us reach our dream house, we’re so thankful and couldn’t recommend her more. We love Lori! 


Medalit & Javier

Dreams Do Come True


Thank you SO much in helping us find the house of our dreams!!!  We are so excited to move our little family to Peekskill.  We hope to see you around and hope you don't mind if we reach out for advice if we need it!!



Ryan, Will & Atticus

Dreams Do Come True


You helped my dreams come true and I'll be forever grateful to you.

Adam P.

5 Star Review


Lori came highly recommended from a very close friend who purchased a home in Westchester County. As a first-time homebuyer, the process can be very overwhelming, especially in a hot market with low inventory.


Lori was extremely patient, knowledgeable, and trusting.


Her knowledge about the area, coupled with an in-depth home comprehension beyond aesthetics (plumbing, electrical, hazardous materials, fixtures, etc.) proved to be a game changer in helping us amicably negotiate with tough sellers to get our house for an amazing price.


Lori is the best and we will definitely call her first should we ever decide to sell our house, as well as happily use her again should we decide to purchase in the same area. 

Vincent C.

5 Star Review

As first time homebuyers, we were nervous about starting and navigating the process. Luckily, we found Lori and she helped us through the whole thing start to finish.

Lori is a patient, kind, and thorough steward of the home buying process. She took the time to explain things to us when we were lost, and helped us feel confident in our decision making. It felt like the decision to buy was informed and we have never questioned our partnership with Lori - she is the very best! Couldn't recommend her more.

Amanda & Fred

A Good Match

Dear Lori,

It was Feb of 2016 when I first spoke to you.  After my conversation with you, I got off the phone and said to my son "that woman is going to sell this house".  Fast forward and here we are closing.

It was a pleasure working with you.  I've heard stories of horror re salespeople but that was totally not the case with you.

I look forward to working with you when I a buy a house.  Thank you.

Regina C.

Above & Beyond

At long last, we made it to the other side of the fence.  I have to thank you for getting me there.  I know you went way over and above the norm to make sure we got this house sold.  Through it all though, you helped me keep positive and take things one step at a time.  You weren't lying when you said you had thick skin.  Well, you really needed it.  Thanks from the bottom of my heart.  I really appreciated all you did.  You're the best!

Matt N.

Both Sides of the Fence

You are a rain maker!

Adam P.

Both Sides of the Fence


Thanks so much. You did a tremendous job and it was a long haul. We are very grateful for all of your help, which made a difficult task for us much easier than it otherwise would have been. Take good care. Thank you for the box, which I assume Whitney has. You have been very thoughtful. 

Bob D.

Dreams Do Come True

Thank you to all who helped and supported us the past 6 months, especially our awesome broker Lori Sheehy!

Rob P.